As the sun sets, our evening menu turns up the heat with rich, soulful dishes that showcase the very best of Caribbean cooking. Enjoy slow-cooked stews, perfectly seasoned seafood, and vibrant vegetarian options, all bursting with spices and flavour. Pair your meal with a rum punch or tropical cocktail and make your evening in Aberystwyth feel like a night in the Caribbean.
Evenings
at Mama Fay's
Served daily from 5pm
HUMMUS & FLAT BREAD
Creamy chickpea hummus served with warm, soft flatbread.
CORN FRITTERS
Served with a lime & cumin dip.
HALLOUMI FRIES
Golden-fried halloumi sticks served with homemade sweet chilli dip.
SPICE GARLIC BUTTER KILLER PRAWNS
Jumbo shell-on prawns cooked in spices garlic butter.
Serving of 3
£7.50
Serving of 6
£13.95
Serving of 9
£15.50
ISLAND GRILLED WINGS
Seasoned to perfection and finished on the fire grill.
Serving of 3
£6.50
Serving of 6
£9.50
Serving of 9
£12.50
Pair these with your mains.
RICE & PEAS
Fragrant rice cooked with kidney beans and coconut milk.
PLAIN RICE
Light, fluffy rice - perfect for soaking up bold island sauces.
CHIPS
Crispy golden fries, lightly salted and served hot.
STEAMED CORN
Steamed corn on the cob with light seasoning and buttery flavour.
All mains come with lime slaw.
ISLAND JERK FIRE HALF-BIRD
Half chicken marinated in signature island Spices and flame-grilled for a smoky finish. Bursting with bold Caribbean flavour. SERVED WITH Gravy, Pick 2 sides.
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
YARD BIRD ROYALE
Flame-grilled whole chicken, seasoned with Fiery jerk spices for tender meat and a smoky Finish. Perfect for sharing-or not. SERVED WITH Gravy, Pick 2 sides.
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
SIZZLIN' JERK PORK LOIN
Thick-cut pork loin marinated in bold jerk spices, Grilled to tender, caramelised perfection Full of heat, smoke, and island flavour. Served with gravy - pick 2 sides
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
THE ISLAND SIRLOIN 12OZ
Juicy sirloin grilled to your liking, brushed With herb-garlic butter. Served with Peppercorn sauce, mushrooms, tomato, Pick 2 sides.
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
JERKED & JUICY CHICKEN STACK
Grilled chicken with island saw and jerk Mayo On a toasted bun. Big Caribbean flavour. Add cheese and upgrade to sweet chips for £1 Gluten Free Bun available
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
ISLAND SMASH
Smashed beef patty with cheese, pickled onions, And Caribbean sauce on a soft bun. A tropical Burger twist. Upgrade to sweet chips for £1 Gluten Free Bun available
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
TRINI TIDE & TURF
Marinated steak and garlic-butter prawns with Island rice, pepper sauce, Pick 2 sides..
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
TASTE OF JAMAICA PLATTER
Curry goat, Half bird, and pork loin served With golden plantain, rice and peas. Bold Jamaican flavour in every bite.
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
SUNSET JERK GRILL
A fiery feast of tender lamb kofta, juicy pork loin, Spicy jerk chicken wings, and Island Jerk Fire Half-Bird. Bursting with authentic Caribbean flavours. SERVED WITH Gravy, Pick 4 sides.
SIDES
RICE & PEAS
PLAIN RICE
CHIPS
CURRY GOAT / MUTTON
Slow-cooked tender goat or mutton in spiced curry sauce. A bold, beloved jamaican classic Pick one side
OXTAIL
Rich and flavoursome cuts of beef prized for its deep taste and tenderness Pick one side
ACKEE AND SALTFISH
Jamaica's national dish - salted cod sautéed with ackee, Onions, peppers & spices Comforting and full of flavour Pick one side
BROWN STEW CHICKEN
Succulent chicken braised in savoury brown gravy. With peppers, onions & island herbs. Pick one side
SEA BASS SHALLOW PAN
Two seabass fillets, shallow-fried in butter with Island spices. Pick one side
POTATO AND CHICKPEA CURRY
Hearty potato and chickpea chunks simmered in fragrant Coconut curry Rich with Caribbean spices Pick one side
JACKFRUIT BURGER WITH SMASHED AVOCADO
Smoky pulled jackfruit with creamy smashed avocado In a soft bun A satisfying plant-based twist Pick one side
HALLOUMI BURGER
Grilled halloumi with fresh salad and island slaw in a toasted Bun Salty, crispy, and delicious Pick one side Gluten free buns available
STEAMED CALLALOO G OKRA STIR-FRY
Vibrant stir-fry of tender callaloo and okra Lightly seasoned and nutrient-rich Pick one side
RICE AND PEAS
Fragrant rice cooked with kidney beans And coconut milk.
PLAIN RICE
Light, fluffy rice - perfect for soaking Up bold island sauces
CHIPS
Crispy golden fries, lightly salted and served hot.
STEAMED CORN ON THE COB
Juicy corn, simply steamed & buttered.
CALLALOO AND OKRA
Hearty leafy green stew with okra Traditional island comfort food
COLESLAW
Creamy and crunchy Caribbean slaw.
STEAMED VEGETABLES
A medley of fresh vegetables gently steamed And seasoned to complement any main dish.
MAC & CHEESE
Creamy. rich macaroni cheese - comfort food Caribbean style.
PLANTAIN
Sweet ripe plantain slices, fried until golden And caramelised - soft, rich, and irresistible.
DUMPLINGS
A combination of sweet and savoury deep fried until golden
FESTIVAL
Slightly sweet deep-fried cornmeal dumplings Crispy outside, soft inside - perfect for dipping
SWEET CHIPS
Thinly sliced sweet potato fries Lightly seasoned and fried crisp
LIME SLAW
Lesty slaw with citrus kick - a fresh contrast.
PLANTAIN CAKE
Moist Plantain cake, baked Golden and served With caramel sauce,
SALTED CARAMEL CHEESECAKE
Velvety cheesecake with salted caramel Sweet, savoury, and indulgent
RUM PINEAPPLE CAKE
Moist rum-infused cake with sweet pineapple Tropical bliss in every bite
MANGO SORBET
Smooth, tangy mango sorbet. A burst of tropical sunshine in every spoonful
RASBERRY SORBET
Vibrant, tangy raspberry sorbet Utterly refreshing. With a zesty berry kick.
TRADITIONAL
Classic vanilla ice cream Creamy, smooth, and simply Indulgent
RUM & RAISIN
Rich rum and plump raisins swirled in a creamy base. Both comforting and sophisticated
CARAMEL & HONEYCOMB
Golden caramel and crunchy honeycomb Perfectly sweet and irresistibly indulgent
COCONUT
Creamy Coconut Ice Cream Silky smooth and tropical. A scoop of paradise